When I finished college, I had an opportunity to move into a yoga center. I’d gotten my Western education, and now I wanted an Eastern one. I was focused on some of the big questions of life: What’s the purpose of life? What happens when you die? How do you deal with the inevitability of death? How beholden to tradition do I need to be?
A few months before moving in to the yoga center, I took a yoga class in the area. The teacher was exceptional, and I approached him after class for some advice. When I told him about my plans, he mentioned that he'd done something similar when he was younger. I asked him what advice he had for me, what was the best thing I could do to prepare, and what should I focus on when I got there?
His advice was much cruder than I expected. He said, “Don’t blow your load.” He told me that if I could go six months without having an orgasm, I could reach enlightenment.
Okay, sounds good, I guess thats what I have to do?
For context, he wasn't the only person saying this. I remember watching a Hong Kong martial arts movie starring Jet Li (which happened to be my original inspiration for considering monastic living and for my interest in traditional martial arts) in which a master attributed his extraordinary powers, including the power of flight, to having "saved his seed."
The idea has been around for thousands of years. In the yoga tradition , it's called brahmacharya. There are Taoist traditions with practices intended to conserve “vital essence.” Across various spiritual traditions, sexual restraint has been used to cultivate discipline, diminish attachment, and redirect one's attention toward spiritual development. Modern psychology also recognizes the benefits of impulse regulation, distress tolerance, and developing the capacity to experience desires without being governed by them.
I took him at his word and I embraced and emphasized this practice. As a neophyte to these traditions, I was a sponge. I've written a lot about this fruitful time period in other blogs so for the purpose of this entry - i'm going to jump ahead 20 years when a friend of mine happened to be working with this yoga teacher’s ex-wife. Completely unprompted, he told me that, according to her, the guy was obsessed with sex and was constantly trying to have sex with her. It had apparently been a major issue in their relationship.Suddenly, I saw his advice in a completely different context. Perhaps when I had asked this guy what I most needed to learn, he had given me the lesson he most needed to learn. His challenge wasn't necessarily my challenge, and his answer wasn't necessarily my answer. He was prescribing his own medicine.
This phenomenon has become of great interest to me. I've had many teachers throughout my life, and I've been a teacher to others as well. When in a teaching position, it's easy to take something important we've discovered about ourselves and elevate it to a universal truth.
“I needed this” becomes “You also need this.”
Maybe you struggled with discipline, and now everyone needs more discipline. Maybe you spent your life pleasing people, discovered boundaries, and now boundaries are the answer to everything. Maybe ambition saved you. Maybe slowing down saved you. Maybe religion saved you. Maybe leaving religion saved you.
It's remarkably easy to confuse your lesson with the lesson.
During my time at the yoga center, I was a big fan of the author Hermann Hesse. His novel Narcissus and Goldmund offers a beautiful illustration of this point. Narcissus is a scholar and a monk who finds meaning through intellectual inquiry, spiritual discipline, and contemplation. Goldmund is a young student who admires him and initially intends to pursue a similar life.But Narcissus recognizes something in Goldmund that Goldmund doesn't yet recognize in himself. He is an artist, a lover, and someone who needs to experience the world rather than withdraw from it. Despite his commitment to his own path, Narcissus helps Goldmund discover that a monastic life is not necessarily the life for him. Goldmund leaves the monastery and experiences love, beauty, art, suffering, loss, and death. He acquires a kind of wisdom that Narcissus could never have imparted to him through instruction alone. And ultimately, Goldmund has something to teach Narcissus.
I find the lesson to be that Narcissus understands that his student may need to do the very things he himself has renounced. The very same teaching that liberates one person could further imprison the other. The message I take from Hesse is not that one of these men has chosen a better life. It's that each must discover and live on his own.
So how does a good teacher help someone do that?
First, I think that they have to become a student of the person they're teaching. They have to listen, observe, ask questions, and become genuinely interested in how that person experiences the world. What are their strengths? What are their struggles? What have they already learned? What are they trying to accomplish? Where are they getting in their own way?
And perhaps most importantly, a teacher needs enough self-awareness to recognize when their own issues are entering the room. That doesn't mean abandoning personal experience. Our experiences are an enormously valuable source of wisdom. But they are a source of information, not a universal prescription. A good teacher also has to be willing to revise their understanding of the student. They may offer a practice, an idea, or a different way of approaching something, but then they need to pay attention to what actually happens. Is this person becoming more capable, more aware, more independent or are they simply becoming better at following the teacher's instructions?
And I think that sometimes, a teacher has to resist the temptation to provide an answer at all. There are things a person needs to discover through living, through experimentation, through making decisions and experiencing their consequences. As a teacher, the goal isn't to create another version of yourself. It isn't to have someone adopt your worldview, overcome your struggles, or arrive at your conclusions. It's to help someone develop the understanding and capabilities they need to navigate their own questions. Sometimes that requires teaching someone the very thing you had to learn. Sometimes it requires teaching them the opposite so they can learn their own lessons.